Why car seats, snowsuits, bulky jackets and bunting bags DON’T MIX!

You know that scene from the movie “A Christmas Story,” the one where Randy’s mom bundles him up in his snowsuit, and he says “I can’t put my arms down!” Here is the scene, posted on YouTube by apuleuis:

To me, this scene highlights our almost compulsive tendency as parents to be sure our babies are safe and warm. I love that scene and I thought of it last winter when we bought my daughter a nice thick snowsuit for our winter walks with the stroller. She couldn’t move much in it, but it sure kept her warm!

My daughter doesn’t wear snowsuits or bulky jackets in her car seat. Lately I feel like I must be a terrible mother when I strap her into her car seat at daycare without her jacket on while all the other kids are strapped in with their bulky jackets. I want to keep my daughter safe and warm too, but did you know bulky jackets/snowsuits, and bunting bags (these look little sleeping bags made to go in a car seat) are not recommended for use in car seats by car seat manufacturers and safety experts?

Why not??

The car seat’s straps or safety harness are designed specifically to be positioned over your little one’s strongest body areas and need to be tight in order to keep the straps in the right place during a collision.  If you are involved in a crash or even stop suddenly, any padding behind your baby (ie. bunting bag) will compress. Bulky jackets and snowsuits on babies or toddlers will also compress. The harness straps will be loose at the very moment you need them to be the tightest. What this means is your child could be partially or fully ejected from their car seat and that is bad news! Check out this link from Consumer Reports to help you figure out if the jacket or snowsuit you are using is safe in the car seat.

To see what I mean, check out these two photos below. In the photo on the left, a child is strapped into his car seat with his jacket on, and the straps are pulled tight. In the photo on the right, the jacket was removed and the child was put back into the seat. The straps were left alone. Look at the amount of slack in the straps the jacket caused! Thick jackets are one of the many reasons why over 4 out of 5 car seats inspected in Halton over the past year failed a random safety check!Child in car seat with bulky jacket both photos

But it’s freezing during the winter! How do I keep my kids warm??

First of all, let’s think about where your baby is spending her time while in that infant seat. The infant seat is usually kept in your warm house, makes a short trip outside into a car that will soon be nice and warm. Maybe you will be doing some shopping, so you decide to keep your baby in her car seat and use the stroller in the warm store. Your baby is now HOT! And probably fussy too.

  • Option 1: Dress your baby in normal clothes. Add a hat, mittens and booties. Then strap him in the car seat and put blankets over top. You can remove the blankets as needed if the car starts to get really warm.
  • Option 2: Exactly like option 1 but instead of using blankets you can purchase a warm cover designed to go OVER the outside of the infant seat.
  • Option 3: Instead of a bulky snowsuit, use a thin snowsuit. A thin fleece snowsuit or sleeper works well, and you can add blankets as needed once your baby is strapped in.

Dressing toddlers and preschoolers for car seats:

  • Option 1: Instead of a bulky jacket, use a thin, well-fitted jacket. If you have a jacket that has a thin fleece inner layer and a detachable outer layer, remove the outer layer before putting him in the car.
  • Option 2: Bring your child to the car with her winter jacket on. Take the jacket off, put her in the car seat and tighten the straps. Then put the jacket on backwards so that her arms are in the sleeves and the back of the jacket acts as a blanket. Your child might get a little cold for the minute it takes to get her strapped in, but soon enough she will be nice and toasty with her jacket on backwards and your car heater on. Bonus: if she gets too hot in your warm car, she can always take her jacket off.

No one ever plans to be in a car crash… but it happens every day. So, this winter, let’s campaign to keep our kids safe in the car: don’t use bulky jackets, bulky snowsuits or bunting bags in car seats. Help us spread the word by sharing this post!

For more information about car seat safety, or to share your story about car seat safety, there are many ways to connect with us:

  • Leave us a comment below
  • Talk to us on Twitter: @haltonparents
  • Email us at haltonparents@halton.ca
  • Call  HaltonParents by dialing 311 or 905-825-6000 for parenting information or to speak directly to a Public Health Nurse (every Monday to Friday from 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.)

About Andrea Scott RN

I’m a public health nurse with the HaltonParents team – you'll find me on Facebook, Twitter and on this blog, writing about all things parenting. I’ve been working for the Halton Region Health Department since 2006 and my focus has been on supporting parents with babies and little kids. I have two little ones myself, “Pumpkin” and “Monkey” who give me plenty to write about! :)
This entry was posted in Babies, Keeping Your Baby Safe, Keeping Your Toddler & Preschooler Safe, Parenting, Parenting Your Baby, Parenting Your Toddler & Preschooler, Toddlers & Preschoolers and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Why car seats, snowsuits, bulky jackets and bunting bags DON’T MIX!

  1. Helen K says:

    Hi Andrea,
    What about a single, young mother with newborn twins.
    She has no car and she needs to take them out in a twin stroller. In that case would a bunting be OK?

    As an aside – she has almost no supports. This new mother lives with her own father, but he’s usually away. They have no car and she doesn’t drive.

    I myself would buy buntings for the 2 babies if you deem them safe for use in a stroller, so I await your advice

    Thanks. Helen.

    p.s. This mother is a friend of my friend.

    BTW – I’m a retired PHN.

    • Andrea Scott RN says:

      Hi Helen,

      Thanks for your comment. Bunting bags are acceptable for use in a stroller, as long as the mom is aware they are not to be used in a car seat for car rides. Bunting bags can be costly – dressing the babies in warm clothes, and then strapping them into the stroller with blankets on top works well too.

      I’m sorry to read she doesn’t have much support. If she lives in Halton Region, you can encourage her to contact us by dialing 311 and we can let her know what supports are available to her in the community. The Healthy Babies Healthy Children program is a voluntary support program, which is available to mothers living in Ontario: http://www.children.gov.on.ca/htdocs/English/topics/earlychildhood/health/index.aspx

      Hope this helps!

      • Helen K says:

        Thanks, Andrea. that helps.

        No, she doesn’t live in Halton. But I’m sending her a couple of practical gifts this Friday and I’ll enclose a gentle and warm note wishing her well and telling her that I’d been a PHN. I’m hoping that in so doing that I can subtly nudge her to call her own health dept! You ladies have a super blog! So proud of you nurses. Helen.

      • Andrea Scott RN says:

        Thanks Helen and and happy to help! Please feel free to email us at haltonparents@halton.ca in the future 🙂

  2. Pingback: 7 tips for when your baby hates their car seat | HaltonParents

  3. Great post! I am actually getting ready to across this information, is very helpful my friend. Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have. Keep up the good work you are doing here.

  4. I believe this is a great site, you are working great on the content and quality of this site at the same time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s